A looming crisis in the childcare sector, where thousands of childminders are set to walk away from their profession, is set to exacerbate an already critical situation for rural families struggling to find appropriate care for their children.

Despite efforts to reduce the financial burden on families in last month’s budget, the childcare crisis continues with less than 15% of childminders in the country signed up to new regulations that require every childminder to be registered with Tusla. This week, the Department of Children extended the registration deadline to 30 June 2030 from the original cut off point of 30 September 2027.

Parents who opt for a childminder to care for their children cannot currently avail of the National Childcare Subsidy (NCS), which is worth up to €96.30 per week for a maximum of 45 hours, unless the childminder is registered.

ADVERTISEMENT

However, the national childminding association, Childminding Ireland, says the government’s proposals to overhaul the sector have the potential to destroy it.

Serious questions

Mairead Hurley, head of childminding services at Childminding Ireland warns that the childcare crisis is going to deteriorate further with an exodus of childminders from the industry if government doesn’t take a step back and review the situation urgently.

“We are extremely concerned about the future of childminding in Ireland, and particularly what the current direction of Government policy could mean for rural communities,” she says.

Mairead Hurley, head of childminding services, Childminding Ireland.

“Childminding is a vital part of our childcare infrastructure, but its importance has not been properly recognised. The 2022 Census showed that approximately 53,000 children were being cared for by childminders, yet Government states the number of childminders to be approximately 13,000.

“Of the 878 childminders who have completed pre-registration training, only 132 have registered through the newer registration process over the past two years. This represents only around 15% of the number who completed pre-registration training and that should be raising serious questions for Government.”

Sarah* is a childminder in Co Roscommon. She has been childminding for 23 years but says this will be her last, as she refuses to sign up to the new regulations.

“Childminding isn’t broken, what they’re going to end up with is an over-regulated system that many people, myself included, just won’t sign up to. I haven’t done the training, and I’ve no intention of doing it, so from next September I will no longer be minding children.

“I’m 61 years of age and would have liked to retire on my own terms but I feel I’m being bullied out of a job I’ve done very well for over 20 years. I’m Garda vetted and have public liability insurance, but I cannot now renew my Garda vetting because I am not signing up to the regulations. It is absolutely ridiculous.”

New regulations threaten to squeeze operators out of the system. \iStock

Garda vetting

Dawn* has been minding children in her home in the Midlands for nearly five years. She says she will not sign up to the new regulations as she does not want to turn her job into a business.

“I do this job because I love the children and I love the work-life balance it gives me. If I was to register with Tusla, it would feel like a business, with paperwork and administration and that’s not what I want,” she says.

“If I have to stop childminding, I will have to go out to work and in that case I will struggle to find childcare for my own children, as we are in a very rural area.”

Dawn adds that Tusla has not offered any training to childminders on how to use the registration system.

“The people who are on the Tusla HIVE system have had to figure it out themselves, and say it’s very restrictive in terms of deadlines for paperwork, in that if it’s not uploaded on a certain date, they won’t get paid.

“My biggest concern is the fact my name and address would be publicly available online if I register with Tusla, which doesn’t make any sense from a safeguarding point of view. The other fear we all have is that if we do register with Tusla, once we’re in that system they can make whatever changes they like and we’ll have no choice but to follow suit.”

Minister for Children, Disabilities and Equality Norma Foley. \ Domnick Walsh

Mairead says shutting childminders off from Garda vetting is a ‘fundamental contradiction’ in what the Government says it is trying to do.

“Childminders who wish to be Garda vetted are unable to access this essential safeguarding measure unless they are prepared to enter a registration system that is not yet mandatory and that the vast majority of childminders do not see as appropriate or workable for them,” she adds.

“Our Parents Survey 2026 has shown that approximately 76% of childminders surveyed were either undecided about registering or indicated that they may leave childminding. There is a very real risk of losing substantial childcare capacity, particularly in rural areas where alternatives may not exist,” adds Mairead.

“If regulatory requirements cause childminders to close, parents will not simply lose access to subsidies. They may lose their childcare altogether.

“Childminders generally work alone in their own homes, without administrative staff or the resources available to larger services. Childminding Ireland is not opposed to regulation, safeguarding or quality assurance. We want children to be safe, parents to have confidence in the care they receive, and childminders to be appropriately recognised and supported.”

Practical aspects

Sarah says the practical aspects of the new regulations convinced her not to sign up.

“Three of the children I mind have been with me since birth and I would regularly bring them with me in to the local supermarket or the chemist,” she adds.

“They’re known in the community and are entirely safe in my care. But that would all stop under the new system as I’d have to carry out a risk assessment to continue doing something I’ve always done.

“I don’t want to finish up, it’s not right. I love the kids, they’re like my own. They’re all friends and while they have their moments, like everyone does, we are all very happy.

Childminding isn’t broken, what they’re going to end up with is an over-regulated system that many people, myself included, just won’t sign up to. I haven’t done the training, and I’ve no intention of doing it, so from next September I will no longer be minding children

“Ours is a normal bungalow in a rural setting which offers a home from home for these children. But the Government don’t realise that, they don’t know what childminding is.

“It’s not a miniature creche, and trying to force the one set of regulations on us all isn’t going to work.

“I am heartbroken to have to finish up. They’re talking about some kind of reprieve, which I will take if it happens. But the Government may say they are listening to us but they are not hearing what we are telling them.”

A spokesperson for the Department of Children, Disability and Equality says the regulations “differ substantially from centre-based childcare”.

“Childminders were consulted on and involved in all aspects of the development of the regulations. In addition, an independent external review of the draft Childminding Regulations has examined the effectiveness of supports made available to support registration of childminders, as well as the barriers to registration and regulatory compliance, including financial and information barriers.

“As part of the registration process, all childminders are required to submit a copy of the vetting disclosure received from the National Vetting Bureau of An Garda Síochána.

“Under the (Children and Vulnerable Persons) Act 2012, Tusla Early Years Inspectorate are considered the relevant organisation in respect of processing the vetting for childminders as part of the registration process.”

*Names have been changed to protect identities.