An Coimisiún Pleanála has refused planning permission for an eight-turbine wind farm at Graffy, near Glenties.

The proposed development by Cuilfeach Teoranta would have covered a 114ac site, with the turbines expected to operate for 30 years.

A planning inspector's report raised concerns about the risk to golden eagles and white-tailed eagles, including the possibility of birds colliding with turbine blades or being displaced from their habitats.

ADVERTISEMENT

A submission from the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage recorded three white-tailed eagle deaths at two nearby wind farms in the previous year, including two within 6km of the proposed site.

The Department also raised concerns about the golden eagle population, citing five breeding pairs in upland Donegal.

The developer disputed some of the findings, arguing that large birds of prey could coexist with wind farms and pointing to mitigation measures used elsewhere.

Highly obtrusive

The proposed development was also considered unsuitable for an area designated for Especially High Scenic Amenity.

The commission described the wind farm as a "highly obtrusive development" that would detract from the natural character of the valley.

While acknowledging the potential benefits of renewable energy, it concluded that the location was unsuitable for the proposed development.

Donegal County Council first refused permission in November 2021, with that decision upheld by An Bord Pleanála in December 2023. The High Court subsequently quashed the appeal decision in March 2025, allowing the case to be reconsidered.

The latest refusal was issued on 3 November, 2026.